Contact Us: 508-325-5500

Nantucket News

New Listing at 17 Milk Street!

Compass Rose is excited to share the news of this new listing at 17 Milk Street which is listed for $1,895,000.

Welcome home to this charming renovated antique in the heart of Nantucket’s Historic District. Modern flair meets traditional detailing in this gem that has been meticulously restored by an award-winning designer and developer. This home features a large open floor plan with multiple living areas, and a first floor master bedroom with en-suite bathroom and laundry area. The upper level contains two bedrooms, a full bath plus a sitting room and sleeping nook. The back patio offers delightfully designed formal gardens, an outdoor shower and generous entertaining space. Opening the double french doors in the main living area creates a beautiful indoor outdoor flow. This home boasts all new heating and cooling systems and off-street parking! Easy stroll to Main St and town.

For more information, or to schedule a showing, please call Richard Matheson at 248-719-1896. You can also reach him by email at


Cynthia Lenhart

Cynthia Sadler Lenhart - Broker with Compass Rose Real Estate, Inc.As the proud founder of Compass Rose Real Estate, Cindy has been selling real estate on Nantucket since 1980. She has served as Treasurer for the Nantucket Association of Real Estate Brokers (NAREB) and on its Professional Standards Committee and Publication Committee. She is a member of Cape Cod & Islands Association of Realtors (CCIAOR), with CBR and GRI designations and is a member of the National Association of Realtors.

She began her real estate career in 1980 at Maury People Real Estate and then spent 13 fruitful years with Congdon & Coleman Real Estate.  She started Compass Rose in 1996 with a small office in her home as a way to better balance raising her two young sons without giving up her career.  As business grew her husband and business partner, Chuck Lenhart built the office at 137A Orange Street where Compass Rose operated for 16 years. In an effort to relieve herself of the long hours of running her own business Cindy made the decision to merge Compass Rose with William Raveis Real Estate in 2021.

Now as the Compass Rose Team at William Raveis she is able to dedicate more time to servicing her clients. Helping people to list and sell their property at the best market price or to find a great house and guide someone through the often-tricky buying process is what she enjoys best about the business. With William Raveis’s excellent 17 Main Street location, advertising budget, superb technology and Cindy’s 40+ years of experience your bound to be very pleased to have engaged her services.